A University of Oxford-led paper describes major gaps in global pandemic preparedness exposed by COVID-19 and sets out interventions needed to manage the next infectious disease emergency.
Drawing on lessons from the COVID-19 pandemic, university researchers have detailed how public health agencies across the world can be better prepared for the next epidemic through effective deployment of Bluetooth contact tracing apps and related digital public health tools.
In a white paper published by the Oxford Martin School Programme on Digital Pandemic Preparedness, academics describe how digital contact tracing tools offered significant potential in the global battle against COVID-19, but that lack of preparation and investment led to delayed deployments and missed opportunities. Whilst Bluetooth-based contact tracing apps were rapidly developed, issues around public trust, privacy, integration, equity, and knowledge sharing took longer to solve and limited their impact.
Professor Christophe Fraser, Director of the Oxford Martin School Programme on Digital Pandemic Preparedness, said: “We are calling on Governments and public health agencies across the globe to ensure that digital tools such as Bluetooth contact tracing apps are ready to support outbreak response from the first days of the next pandemic. Digital tools can make a substantial contribution to epidemic control, but most countries remain unprepared to deploy and govern these tools effectively. Whilst refining the technology is a core part of the solution, there needs to be greater focus on building ethical, trusted and interoperable digital public-health infrastructure in advance of the next outbreak.”
Digital tools can make a substantial contribution to epidemic control, but most countries remain unprepared to deploy and govern these tools effectively.
Professor Christophe Fraser
The white paper describes how digital contact tracing apps were deployed in at least 90 countries during COVID-19, with an estimated 600 million users worldwide. However, there were vast differences in how the apps were received. In some countries there was low uptake and the apps had no measurable impact on the epidemic. Other countries saw record-breaking uptake, strong engagement, and correspondingly large epidemiological impacts.
Professor Michael Parker, a co-author of the paper, said: “It is clear that well-designed digital tools have the potential to make a significant contribution to pandemic preparedness and response. That is, to saving lives, reducing suffering, and enabling more informed, less intrusive, public health interventions. However, these important benefits will only be achievable if the development and deployment of digital tools is equitable and deserving of well-founded public trust and confidence.”
The paper discusses the interdependence of elements of the public health ‘toolkit’, particularly the natural dependence of contact tracing on diagnostic testing. A key benefit of digital contact tracing is that it can easily scale up to meet population demand, whereas laboratory tests have natural limits on daily capacity and turnaround times. Symptom-based alerts and rapid home tests can play a role in supporting the case-finding system, and a robust public health response would be adaptable to rapidly changing intervention options and epidemic dynamics.
Delays to app deployments, which limited their ability to support the pre-vaccine phase of the pandemic, are also highlighted by the paper as an area for improvement.
Dr Michelle Kendall, who led the writing of the paper, said: “In countries where digital contact tracing apps were effective, they had a considerable impact on reducing transmissions, hospitalisations and deaths. However, many were only deployed after the first epidemic wave, after key therapeutic interventions had been discovered, and only shortly before vaccine roll-outs began. The digital tools were not available when they could have had maximal impact.
With some ‘peacetime’ investment, digital contact tracing apps could be ready to play a key, low-cost role in mitigating infectious disease transmission from Day 1 of a future outbreak.”
Preparing for the next pandemic
The white paper identifies three key requirements for digital public health tools to be ready to support the response to the next infectious disease emergency:
- Day 1 readiness. The majority of the design work and testing of digital tools should take place between emergencies rather than in the midst of an outbreak, with expert input from behavioural science, ethics, technology, public health and epidemiology, and engagement with relevant publics, particularly communities at risk of exclusion or disproportionate harm. Platform approaches which can be quickly tailored to the pathogen and setting would enable gaps and solutions to be identified rapidly in a crisis, and peacetime use cases would keep the technology warm and ready to scale up in an emergency.
- Public health integration. Digital tools need to be integrated by public health agencies into their wider ‘toolkit’ of outbreak response, and regularly updated in line with the changing dynamics of an outbreak and developments in our understanding of symptoms and risk factors.
- Autonomy-preserving data and analytics. Digital tools should collect data in a way that preserves the privacy of users and is acceptable to the public, whilst providing public health agencies with sufficient and relevant data. Processes for the collection, storage, analysis and reporting of data should be confirmed now, ahead of the next outbreak.
This article is republished from the Pandemic Sciences Institute website. Read the original article here.