Why two cups of coffee can have very different environmental outcomes

16 November 2026

Close-up of a cluster of coffee cherries at different stages of ripeness, ranging from green and yellow to orange and deep red, growing on a coffee plant surrounded by glossy green leaves.
Researchers studying 1,500 coffee farms in Kenya and Vietnam have found striking differences in environmental outcomes, yields and farmer livelihoods, even between farms operating in similar conditions. Could better information help farmers improve their livelihoods and be better for the planet?

Coffee is one of the world’s most important crops. supporting the livelihoods of around 25 million farming households worldwide. Most are small-scale farmers, often working just an acre or so of land, with limited access to training, finance or information about the consequences of different farming practices.

They also face growing pressures. Climate change is making harvests less predictable, production costs are rising, and farmers are increasingly expected to demonstrate that their coffee is produced sustainably.

Researchers from the University of Oxford's HESTIA Farm Trials programme, working with partners in Kenya and Vietnam, are investigating why farms operating in similar conditions can achieve such different results, and whether sharing information about farm outcomes could help farmers learn from one another, improve environmental outcomes and improve their livelihoods.

The researchers joined food creators Sorted Food to explore what these findings could mean for the future of coffee production.

Learning from what farmers already know

One of the ideas behind the research is simple: useful knowledge already exists within farming communities, but it isn't always easy to access or share.

A farmer may know how much coffee they harvested last season, but not how their yields, water use or environmental outcomes compare with those of neighbouring farms. Nor might they know whether a different farming practice could improve their results.

The researchers are using HESTIA, an open-access platform developed at the University of Oxford to measure and compare the environmental outcomes of agricultural production, to assess farms consistently. By sharing these findings with farmers, alongside information about practices used by others, they hope to help farmers identify opportunities to improve their own outcomes.

Of course, information alone may not be enough. Farmers can face financial or practical barriers to changing their practices, and what works well on one farm may not work on another. Understanding these challenges is an important part of the research.

But if the approach proves effective, it could offer a relatively low-cost way to support more sustainable coffee production, building on farmers' own knowledge and experience.

Understanding why farms facing similar challenges achieve such different results, and whether farmers can learn from those differences, could help identify practical ways to improve both livelihoods and environmental outcomes.

Coffee farming in practice: Case studies from Kenya and Vietnam 

Kenya: Can better information change farming practices? 

Kenya is home to exceptional biodiversity, particularly in its coffee-growing landscapes. It also has more than 800,000 smallholder coffee-farming households, many of whom face low incomes and limited access to agricultural advice.

The Kenya research, funded through the Darwin Initiative and led by Dr Alice Karuri at Strathmore University in collaboration with the University of Oxford, is working with 500 farmers to understand how agricultural practices relate to environmental and livelihood outcomes.

Farmers will receive farm-specific feedback showing their farm’s outcomes, how their results compare with those of similar farms, and what practices are being used by peers with the best outcomes for livelihoods and the planet. The team will assess whether access to this information encourages farmers to change their practices, and whether those changes improve outcomes.

Vietnam: Making farm data useful to farmers

Vietnam is the world's second-largest coffee producer and a major supplier of Robusta coffee. Much of its coffee production is concentrated in the Central Highlands, where it supports hundreds of thousands of smallholder households.

However, the expansion of coffee production has contributed to deforestation and pressure on water resources. Farmers also face increasingly unpredictable weather, fluctuating prices and new demands for environmental traceability.

The Vietnam research, funded through EU Horizon and the Login 5 Foundation and led by Dr Van Hai Nguyen at PanNature in collaboration with the University of Oxford's HESTIA and Flourishing Landscapes teams, has collected data from 1,000 coffee farms to investigate differences in environmental outcomes and resilience.

Together, the two projects aim to understand how better farm-level information could support more sustainable coffee production. 

The Kenya research is funded by the Darwin Initiative. The Vietnam research is funded by EU Horizon (project 101182025) and the Login 5 Foundation. The Oxford-based team works across the Oxford Martin School, the Department of Biology, and the Smith School of Enterprise and the Environment. HESTIA is the key output of the Oxford Martin Programme on Food Sustainability.